5. The vintage sign and awning of McSorleys Old Ale House is not just for appeal: Its remained relatively unchanged since it opened in 1854. The Lasagna at Da Nico is in a league of its own! Don't be surprised if you run into a celebrity here; it's a common spot for celebrity sightings, which the restaurant proudly boasts with its photo wall of those that have dined there in the past. 12 Best Little Italy Restaurants NYC That Are Actually Good (+ What To Order). Pollo con Gamberi alla Francese is an Italian-American favorite where you get golden pan fried chicken and jumbo shrimp nice and crispy, and cooked in a buttery and delicious lemon sauce. In Manhattan's Little Italy, multiple dining rooms and seating capacities over 100 are the norm. Location: 2155 Hylan Blvd, Staten Island Di Palo's Fine Foods is one of the best stores to take home imported Italian goods and wines. Where: 195 Grand St. 4. Current Owner(s): Descendants of Anthony (Totonno) Pero What: The little neck clam pizza and diavola are absolute musts. Our goal is to help you easily find the best food and things to do in the city! Our Menu highlights : Casa DAngelos signature prime cut filet mignon, pappardelle topped with the goodness of fresh herbed tomato sauce, garlic infused with mushrooms, & vegetable medley. Especially in summer Da Nico is a popular restaurant because of the many outdoor seating possibilities. Register now - its free! . Waiting in long lines isn't for everyone, but if there's a line everyone should be willing to wait in, it's the one out the door of Emilio's Ballato. (Basically, picture the early scenes of Hamilton.) Besides wine, when one thinks, Boston is one of the most historical cities in America and was the center of the American Revolutionary War. The lemony white wine sauce is so good, you better save some bread to soak it all up. (Were spoiled in other ways, too, but thats not the point.) Petto di Pollo alla Emilio is an indulgent dish. This fine-dining restaurant and event space, located on the 65th floor of 30 Rock, was originally opened back in 1934. "the place to go in little italy". New York has a lot of eateries, but these classic Italian old-school joints will make you feel like you're eating in your nonna's kitchen. And their spicy rotinibasically everything! What: The coal oven pizzas from Lombardis are famous, and the spot is often called NYCs first pizzeria. Also located on Staten Island is the acclaimed Italian restaurant Pier 76. "After a remarkable 130 years, my. You can have your Chicken Parm here as a sandwich or with spicy rotini pasta (Chicken Parm Dinner), and it will taste good both ways. There are plenty of restaurants to choose from around Little Italy's main drag, but I recommend two in particular: Tra Di Noi, on East 187th, and Zero Otto Nove, on Arthur Avenue proper. The pizza at Patsys is so good that it attracted a number of celebrities including Frank Sinatra, Joe DiMaggio, Dean Martin, Francis Ford Coppola, Al Pacino, and Robert DeNiro. 14 Oldest Restaurants in Las Vegas Address: 165 Mulberry Street, New York, NY 10013. For visitors who find themselves anywhere, even remotely, in the area of Randazzo's, it is worth it to try some of their famous gal-ah-mah with spicy red sauce for themselves. Cuisines Italian Hours of operation Daily 11:00 am-10:00 pm Phone number (212) 965-1188 Website http://www.paesanosoflittleitaly.com/index.html Payment options AMEX, Discover, JCB, MasterCard, Visa Dress code Smart Casual Catering Please contact Paesano's directly for catering inquiries Location 136 Mulberry Street, New York, NY 10013 Neighborhood 10 Largest Pizzas Ever Made, Your email address will not be published. Spanish Harlem -- El Barrio -- became home to one of the oldest pizza places in New York City (at one point it was the oldest running pizzeria) in 1933. Made in-house from scratch, it has ample cheesy layers, a drool-worthy marinara sauce, and a few of the chefs tricks that make it this delish. Covered in housemade tomato sauce and cheese, this is a surefire winner. Auto. Year Opened: 1950 Celebrating 103 years, Puglia is a family-owned and -operated restaurant serving Southern Italian delicacies in a fun and lively atmosphere, with drink specials and nightly entertainment. Current Owner(s): JPeter Castellotti Sr. and Robert Bob Vittoria Like all of the other early New York pizzerias, Patsys Pizzeria was founded by Italian immigrants Pasquale Patsy and his new wife Carmella Lancieri. Everything is made to order. Services. Caff Roma has always been another popular hangout spot for visitors and locals. Master Pizzaoiula Giorgia brings one of Italy's oldest and most profound humble dishes to her Manhattan eatery, Don Antonio. In 2010, Deninos opened a second location on the Jersey Shore and the pizzeria is now franchising. Our Picks for the 9 Best Restaurants in Little Italy (NYC) 12. was a hundred years ago when Italian immigrants first settled here. The bestseller is the Favoloso, piled high with salame toscano, pecorino cream, artichoke cream, and spicy eggplant, but for something funky, go for the Sweet Treat For The Fall, a monstrous sandwich with lardo, truffle honey, and gorgonzola. From pizzas cooked in an authentic coal-fired oven, to a wide array of other Italian dishes, this place serves standout meals in a memorable atmosphere. Dont forget to try their Ice Cream Cake; classic or smores, youll enjoy it! What: At this famous spot the littleneck clams on the half shell are fresh, ice-cold, and outrageously delicious. Taco trucks might line nearly every block of Manhattan today, but back in 1984, when founder Josefina Howard opened the first Rosa Mexicano on the Upper East Side, it was considered novel to many East Coasters. Today, Nunzios is owned by Robert Whiteaker. 16 Best Little Italy restaurants in NYC - Time Out New York We met with the Governors office and got lip service, King said. Year Opened: 1937, but did not start serving pizza until 1951 Current Owner(s): Robert Whiteaker It has been serving delicious pizza and Italian dishes since 1960 with a pizza that rivals the best in the five boroughs. . Tastewise, the dessert just hits the spot! No? America's First Pizzeria | Little Italy NYC | Lombardi's I hope so., Ernies shop is special because it is a landmark in Little Italy, said Wissner. What to order: Vongole Oreganate, Tagliatelle alla Bolognese, Gamberi Fra Diavolo, Petto di Pollo alla Emilio, Address: 55 E Houston Street, New York, NY 10012. Year Opened: 1905 Fior d'Italia is the oldest Italian restaurant in the US (Anthony Dolce/Flickr) Fior d'Italia offers today a deliciously traditional fair of Italian cuisine, including escargots, burrata, cabbage soup, tortellini alla panna, pumpkin ravioli, pesto trenette, several varieties of risotti, ossobuco, chicken alla Valdostana. Have you tried bruschetta with zucchini? If you are having any trouble with the reservation booking tool, please call us at 212 925 8775 or email us at contact@bleugrotta.com and we will be happy to make a reservation for you. Great Wall Chinese Restaurant. If one can't decide which New York City Pizzeria to visit, then consider going on a pizzeria tour of the Big Apple. The chicken is thinly pounded, breaded, and pan-fried to attain a crispy exterior, and is still juicy inside. Year Opened: 1942 Here are six reasons you have to visit Little Italy while you're in New York City. Go on a pizza tour and have a very different experience in NYC. Thanks for contacting us. What to order: Lasagna, Calamari Fritti, Prosciutto & Arugula pizza, Pollo Rollatini, Address: 164 Mulberry, Street, New York, NY 10013. While you can, of course, settle with Puglias Famous Rigatoni alla Vodka, there is one other special dish you shouldnt miss Homemade Stuffed Rigatoni. Restaurants. Last April, aGoFundMewas set up to keep the store afloat as he finds himself in danger of closing for good. Lombardi is credited with developing New York Style pizza and making Lombardi's the first pizzeria in the United States. restaurants coffee shops pizza chinese mexican burgers italian japanese french. Your email address will not be published. The calamari is crispy and not greasy; drizzle some lemon on top and dip each bite into the tomato sauce on the side to make it tastier. New York City Little Italy Guide to History and Culture - NYCgo.com Then youve come to the right place because Ill show you the hottest and most authentic places where New Yorkers hang out. Nunzios Pizzeria was opened in 1942 by Nunzio Trivoluzzo and it is one of the oldest pizzerias in Staten Island. Lombardi's, which opened in 1905, is credited with developing the New York-style pizza and with being the first pizzeria in the United States. The audience is colourful: from families with children to couples and business espresso guests. Log into myNY and start planning your New York trip. Our goal is for all our customers to have a warm, welcoming experience. What: A pizza is a must-order item when you visit Emporio. When this famous shop first opened its doors in 1914, it was known as an appetizing store, aka store that sells the food one eats with bagels. A century later, the business is still in the family. A century later, the business is still in the family. Buona Notte is a hidden gem of a restaurant located in the heart of Little Italy. Year Opened: c. late 1920s/early 1930s Every restaurant in Little Italy claims to have the best cannoli, but the only one with the line to prove it is Ferrara Bakery. But, little do people know that this sprawling neighborhood is a tourist trap, with a long list of mediocre restaurants trying to lure people to dine in their place. steffen@loving-newyork.com, For any other questions please contact:hello@loving-newyork.com, About us |Imprint & Contact |Privacy Policy |Terms & Conditions |Cancellation Terms. Either way, youll end the meal with a powdered sugar zeppole. This place also has one of the best turkey sandwiches The Slow Roasted Turkey. Opened in 1900, it's ironic that a joint as old and classic as Bamonte's still stands, nearly unchanged from its opening days, in an area that has been swarmed with gentrification. How can it not be there after so many years?. I was really hoping that this day would never come and its a sad one.. Their best-sellers are their orecchiette in rabbit ragu, a nod to the Puglia region from which Dora originates, and their pappardelle del ristoro with wild boar. This old-school joint is one of Manhattan's most popular for a good reason. But, the show stopper is certainly the sauce, which is beef, pork, and veal ragu; it is hearty, full of flavor, and out of this world! All items are sold "as is" and on a first come, first served basis. The 10 Oldest Pizza Joints In New York City - Business Insider The Pollo Rollatini has a beautifully cooked, crunchy chicken cutlet stuffed with salty prosciutto and fresh mozzarella, and the marsala mushroom sauce is luxuriously sweet and savory. DiVittorio and his father bought Eddies in the early 1980s and added a dining room. Visiting NYC? Where to Eat (and Avoid) in Little Italy and Chinatown She acknowledges that while Lombardis is the oldest/first pizzeria in the country, her grandfather is who needs to be credited with bringing pizza to America. Welcome to Lombardi's, America's oldest pizzeria | New York holidays Even if fried dough isn't quite your thing, Don Antonio has a wide offering of Neopolitan-style pizza, and the menu even gives insight into the old history of the origins of classics such as Margherita and Pizze Fritte. It is unbelievably cheesy and is layered to perfection so you get a complete bite of the pasta, cheese, and sauce every time. "solid place of many years". Inspired by the warmth and comfort of the Italian countryside, Olio e Pi and Chef Pedro Cruz bring tradition and authentic Italian cuisine to the West Village. What: If youre looking for delicious pizza, Da Nico is where to go. Where Italian culinary tradition is celebrated in a romantic, candle-lit. Enjoy traditional Northern and Southern Italian cuisine at Da Nico. The first Italians arrived in Harlem in 1878 from Salerno in southwest Italy, and settled around East 115th Street. What to order: Campesante con Carciofi e Parmigiano, Fettuccine di Parma, Pollo con Gamberi alla Francese, Address: 125 Mulberry Street, New York, NY 10013. The restaurant still offers up authentic, regional Mexican cookingits the kind of place that brings over your guacamole ingredients and mashes everything right in front of youand a damn good margarita, to boot. 8 Most Expensive Pizzas in the World What: This vegetarian restaurant makes great cauliflower pizzas and is a solid breakfast/brunch spot. What: A wine bar in Little Italy, they also have wonderful small plates like beef tartare and confit rabbit. 15 Best Pizza Places in Little Italy, NY [2023 Updated] - Bella Bacinos . Johns of Bleekcer Street was opened in 1929 by John Sasso, an immigrant from Naples, Italy. This classic American steakhouse originally went by the name Tidewater Trading Post thanks to the fact that the Hudson River once crept as far east as Ninth Avenue (its since receded). Tiramisu is also made in-house and comes to your table fresh. Ray's Pizza, and its many variations such as "Ray's Original Pizza", "Famous Ray's Pizza" and "World-Famous Original Ray's Pizza", are the names of dozens of . The service is exceptionally friendly and the food is fabulous. Their traditional Italian pastries are created on the premises such as cannoli, tiramisu and pasticciotto. Little Italy Beverly Pizza Home Beverly Massachusetts. We've received your submission. At the time, it joined a neighborhood that was home to mostly meat purveyors. Best Little Italy Restaurants in NYC - Tinybeans Required fields are marked *. Reportedly, J & V Pizzeria was one of the first pizza places to sell pizza by the slice, which is still offered today. Despite only being open since February 2022, this 44-seat eatery sells out just about every single night, so you'll want to make plans far in advance to ensure you can snag a spot. One doesn't have to stroll far along the streets of Poughkeepsie's Mount Carmel Little Italy district to come across a bakery or restaurant that reaches back into the century-old culinary traditions brought to the Hudson Valley by Italian emigrants. To help you quickly and easily see which spot is near you, you can find all of Little Italy restaurants on an interactive map. 15 E. Seventh St.; mcsorleysoldalehouse.com. a nonprofit restaurant . Less is more, as they say, and if there's one type of cuisine that brings that statement home, it's Italian. The food comes from the hands of a real Italian family. We look forward to welcoming you! 13. This high-end American steakhouse is one for the books. Along with the nice and juicy chicken, the pasta tastes extremely delicious. Check out Poughkeepsie's Little Italy - Hudson Valley One The original location of Nunzios was in South Beach and it was moved to its current location on Hylan Boulevard in 1960. Know that no matter what you order, from osso bucco to shrimp fra diavolo, you're in good hands. Pizzamaker Vito at J&V Pizzeria in Bensonhurst, Brooklyn. 612 Crescent Avenue Bronx, NY 10458. (Not only is this method the most time-consuming and expensive way to age beef, but most places these days just dont have the space that was allotted to steakhouses back then.). Once prohibition was repealed, the pool hall started serving beer in 1933. 10 Oldest Pizzerias in the World (Still in Operation) 1905 | NYC Since 1905 Gennaro Lombardi crafted pizza in the United States using his bakers trade he learned from Naples. If you like mushroom, we recommend tasting the speck and mushroom pie. Location: 235 Mulberry St, New York, NY 10012, United States. Its Art Deco design is still one to be admired, with chocolate-brown leather banquettes, nickel-trimmed glass tabletops, a black granite bar and, 24-karat-gold-leaf-covered ceiling and distinct murals on the walls painted by Bemelmans himself. Umberto's roots reach back to 1972, when Ianniello's father first opened the restaurant's doors. His grandfather would scout both tunes and talent, leading him to launch his own publishing company. Antonio's Trattoria. After closing due to the state-mandated COVID-19 shutdown and reopening in late 2020, Rossi developed diverticulitis and was subsequently hospitalized. For New York diners looking for something a bit more traditional, try one of these spots for classic Italian food. The narrow streets teemed with children and resonated . 56 Ninth Ave.; theoldhomesteadsteakhouse.com, Home to one of the citys classic burgers, P.J. Umberto's Clam House - Opened in 1972, today this seafood restaurant is run by the family's second generation. Whether you are here for a celebration, family gathering, business meeting, dinner or lunch we promise you a good time with great food. Main article: Where in New York should you stay? Great Italian food in the oldest restaurant in Little Italy, NYC Shop at the Trendiest Stores Di Palo's Fine Foods 200 Grand St, New York, NY 10013 Phone: 212-226-1033 Visit Website Source Who says you can't take Italy home? Gambas Al Ajillo is a yummy Spanish dish with big, plump, and juicy shrimp swimming in mouth-watering garlic-parsley sauce. Legal. Note: apart from the a la carte menu, Puglia also offers pre-fixed dinner menus featuring their signature dishes that will be served family-style. The Gelso & Grand is a successful mix of a restaurant (with excellent pizza), a bar and a small outdoor area. Made with a medley of beef, pork, and veal, the meatballs are fresh and homemade and taste spectacular in the hearty tomato sauce. If youd like to make your dish more filling, you could add Meatballs with their Spaghetti alla Chitarra. The earthy and umami truffle cream on the side is the perfect dip for these fried risotto balls. Bon apptit! One of the oldest street foods in the world is pizze fritte, or "fried pizza," classically found in Naples, Italy, still to this day. Little Italy. We forgive its lack of progressiveness in lieu of the fact that you can still order a pint of the house beer for $5 and enjoy a bare-bones cheese plate for $4, which comes with crackers and the bars infamous mustard (a homemade mix of Colmans hot mustard powder and dark ale). This intimate eatery serves up delicious Italian dishes made with the freshest ingredients, along with a selection of fine wines. The selection of Italian restaurants in Little Italy is unsurprisingly large so theres bound to be something for you! >>. Even the late and great Anthony Bourdain paid homage to Randazzo in his Brooklyn episode of No Reservation. What: Feel free to venture out of your comfort zone here. The menu features anywhere between 18 and 20 pastas, with classics that you'd find right in Italy without the hassle of booking a flight to Rome. What to order: Meatballs, Spaghetti alla Chitarra with Meatballs, Classic pizza, Vodka pizza, Lumache alla Vodka, Tiramisu, Address: 235 Mulberry Street, New York, NY 10012. Wood-fired food, Neo-NY style pizza, and an extraordinary wine program that sums up pretty much what Pasquale Jones is all about! Contact: nomannomad.net@gmail.com. Here is the ultimate list of the best Little Italy restaurants NYC that you should bookmark for your next visit to Manhattan. 02 La Mela Location: 524 Port Richmond Avenue, Staten Island. New York Foodie | @BLfoodie | Flipboard This exceptional restaurant, with its open kitchen, excellent service, and elegant setting, has an upscale yet relaxed vibe. The place is joyful and full of energy, just how an Italian family would be. Italian restaurant, Manhattan, New York City. A post shared by Aunt Jakes (@aunt.jakes). Copyright 2023 OpenTable, Inc. 1 Montgomery St Ste 700, San Francisco CA 94104 - All rights reserved. This wonderful restaurant and pizzeria is a popular joint in Little Italy. The sidewalk clam bar was located at the corner of Mott and Hester street in Little Italy, New York City, Where it still flourishes today, serving succulent varieties of Italian Seafood. Year Opened: 1924 Current Owner(s): Adem Brija For Rossi, the store gives him a reason to carry on in the face of terrible loss. TOP 12 best places to eat in Little Italy, NYC - That we know you'll The original bar was burned down in the 1970s and Eddies moved down the street. Damage from. Family we like. Rubirosa is our top pick for classic New York Italian with great pizza, pastas, a gargantuan-but-delicious chicken parm, and housemade mozzarella that's some of our favorite in the city. 30 Rockefeller Plaza, 65th floor; rainbowroom.com, The 21 Most Stunning Wedding Venues in NYC. However, if youre looking for something safe and delicious we suggest going with the octopus (Polpi in Purgatorio) and the lamb chops (agnello con polenta). My grandfather used to go back to Naples every year to participate in the Festival of Piedigrotta, Rossi said of the now-defunct music festival which began in the 1800s. Today, folks still come all over for its historic charm as well as its cheap beer and pub fare like chicken potpie and burgers. Whatever diners choose to order, they can't go wrong, but starting off with an order of panzerotti, or baby fried calzones, is probably not a bad idea. Known to be one of the first New York City establishments that served pizza by the slice, J&V has kept it simple since day one. She sold Patsys to Frank Brija in 1991 and his son, Adem Brija, owns the pizzeria today. Another relative of Sasso and the Vesces, Bob Vittoria, and his business partner Peter Castellotti Sr. took over Johns in the 1970s. And for a dollar Id buy five slices of Sicilian pizza and a couple of Cokes.. The audience is colourful: from families with children to couples and business espresso guests. The pasta is homemade, fresh, and cooked to al-dente perfection. For those who are looking for something old-school on the go and happen to find themselves in the uber-Italian neighborhood of Bensonhurst, Brooklyn, look no further than J&V Pizzeria. The leading independent voice for aviation news and insight. They also offer an extensive gluten-free menu for guests. 872 reviews Closed Now. Beauty. You'll often find owner James Bari seated outside this small eight-table restaurant which dates back to 1968. The Empire State Building: Is it worth going up to the 102nd floor? It opened in 1817 as a tobacco shop, became a brewery in 1890, a speakeasy during the Prohibition era and, rumor has it, at some point may have served as a brothel and smugglers den. Little Italy (also Italian: Piccola Italia) is a neighborhood in Lower Manhattan in New York City, known for its large Italian population. After years of evolution and recipes passed down from generation to generation, including their famous "gal-ah-mah" (calamari), Randazzo's Clam Bar was born. Alleva was a great store. Location: 278 Bleecker Street, New York City Price of Margherita or Cheese Pizza: $17 (medium) or $20 (large). The restaurant is complete with a wine and sangria bar, and this is one of those places where you can see a diverse array of people, from tourists to New Yorkers. Of course, you could go classic and enjoy the beautifully done Margherita, or take the pasta route and try the Sunchoke Tortelli, an interesting but extremely tasty flavor combination of hazelnut, sage, and balsamic. Hotels. The Nutella calzone dessert is also heavenly. Sign up to our newsletter for the latest and greatest from your city, Dont Be FooledThis New Italian Restaurant Isnt Exactly An Italian Restaurant, 14 Best Jazz Clubs In NYC For An Evening Of Live Music, 15 Experiences To Gift The Most Memorable Days Out In NYC, An Epic Japanese Food Fest Is Coming To NYC This Month. Chinatown got money. Cheddar. February 12, 2010. One of New York's oldest and most exclusive restaurants, Rao's is known as much for its old-school Italian food as the famous faces it feeds. Little Italy in NYC: Top 6 Reasons (and Places) to Visit When you order Spaghetti Pomodoro here, remember to add meatballs at an extra cost. Top 10 Things To Know About The Empire State Building, The Best Hotels near the Empire State Building, One World Observatory The Complete Guide, The Complete Guide to Broadway Shows in New York. The scallops come cooked just right, are buttery, and have a bit of sweetness to them. What: With a lovely garden atrium, this Little Italy staple has been around since 1975 and has something on the menu for everyone. The backyard is very romantically designed and invites you to linger. On Saturday morning, the old heart of the neighborhood took another hit when a fire broke out at Angelo's of Mulberry St., said to be the oldest Italian restaurant in the area. Da Nico Ristorante - This is also a family operated restaurant that has been open since 1993. It's sometimes difficult to find the best places to eat in Little Italy, NYC, as many are tourist traps that serve up average food that's not worth the cash. Owing to its name, the restaurant serves a bomb Chicken Parmesan, and extensive Italian-American fare in a hip, diner-like place. Year Opened: 1937, but did not start serving pizza until 1951. What to order: Truffle Arancini, Margherita pizza, Spaghetti Pomodoro with meatballs, Brown Butter Gnocchi, Address: 186 Grand Street, New York, NY 10013. "showcase how the hungry kids that changed the New York specific Italian food scene became legendary." more. T here are almost 75,000 pizzerias in the US, and the granddaddy of them all is Lombardi's, an unassuming place opened more than a century ago at 32 Spring Street, in New York's Little Italy . Lombardis was opened in 1905 by Gennaro Lombardi, who is regarded as the father of American pizza. La Mela has been delighting people with delicious and generous portions of Italian food for over thirty years. It is the original home of Vincent's Sauce. If youre a pesto person, the Pesto di Rucola e Pistaccio is your dish. It's been delighting New Yorkers with the classic hamburger in its true and simplest form since 1961 and have now expanded to several locations around the citythough its very first location in the West Village is still in existence. Not only has it garnered just about every award known to the restaurant industry, but the building in which it was first established has served as a steakhouse since 1897which is one of the reasons the restaurant is able to dry-age its steaks in-house. 4. Come and dine with your Paesans, only at Paesano's of Mulberry Street. The Littleneck Clam Pizza is a standout dish from their menu. Price of Margherita or Cheese Pizza: $14. The interior is lined with welcoming sidewalk tables, warmly decorated and designed to provide you an unforgettable, romantic ambiance. How to Find Old New York in Manhattan's Vanishing Little Italy Sasso and his family continued to run Johns until 1954 when the pizzeria was sold to the Augustine and Joe Vesce, who were distantly related to Sasso. Gelso & Grands Truffle Arancini are a terrific way to start your meal at the restaurant. Little Italy | The Official Guide to New York City - NYCgo.com The longstanding cheese connoisseur has not only drawn generations of families to its long menu of Italian delicacies, fresh mozzarella, ricotta, cured meats and cannolis, but Allevas Dairy was also known to attract famous faces from around the world. The meat is always moist and flavorful and has a beautiful herby flavor. 8. While I was in the hospital, my wife Margaret said, Ernie, Im going to keep the store open. I told her, No, leave it closed. She said, No, youre gonna be closed for too long.. What: This grocery store doubles as a sandwich shop that makes a hearty Italian sandwich. This 130-year-old business's Manhattan storefront is parma-gone and mozzarel-ocating to the Garden State.